Study shows mixed attitudes toward media and news fatigue
If you’ve ever felt like your morning scroll through the headlines is more of a chore than a choice, you aren’t alone. A recent Pew Research Center study from the Pew-Knight Initiative reveals that Americans have developed a complicated relationship with the news. While many still consider staying informed a pillar of democracy, the actual act of consuming the news is leaving many of us with news fatigue: exhausted, skeptical, and ready to disconnect.
Here are some of the more interesting highlights from the study and what they suggest about our digital lives and mental wellness today.
1. The Civic Responsibility Paradox
The study found a fascinating tension in how we view the news. On one hand, 80% of Americans believe it is a responsibility to be informed when we vote.
On the other hand, when asked what makes a “good member of society,” following the news ranks surprisingly low. It sits well below voting, paying taxes, and volunteering. Only 11% of adults consider following the news “extremely important” to being a good citizen. Essentially, Americans think being informed is a requirement for responsible voting, but not necessarily for being a good neighbor.
2. The Shift from “Hunters” to “Gatherers”
How do you get your news? A few years ago, you probably would be more of a “hunter” actively seeking out specific media outlets or programs. In 2019, 60% of Americans said they mostly looked for news.
Today, that’s changed. It’s an even split: 50% seek news, while 49% say they mostly just “come across” it. In an era of social media algorithms and push notifications, the news has a way of finding us whether we want it or not. This “news finds me” mentality has also led many to believe they can stay informed without any active effort.
3. DIY Fact-Checking and Trust Issues
One of the most telling findings is our confidence—or lack thereof—in others. An overwhelming 94% of Americans believe it’s at least somewhat important to “do your own research” to check the accuracy of a story.
But here’s the kicker: we trust ourselves far more than others. About 29% of us are “very confident” in our own ability to spot fake news, but only 3% feel that same level of confidence in other people’s abilities. We’ve become a nation of amateur investigators who are suspicious of each other.
4. The Rise of News Fatigue
If you feel tired just reading this, you’re in the majority. 52% of U.S. adults express news fatigue saying they are worn out by the sheer volume of news. It’s not just the quantity, either, but the relevance. Nearly half of Americans feel that most of the news they encounter is not relevant to their lives.
This disconnect and exhaustion is leading to a mass tuning out. The study found that 60% of people have reduced their overall news intake, and two-thirds have walked away from a specific news source entirely. Perhaps most surprisingly, only 9% of people follow the news because they actually enjoy it. For the rest of us, it’s either a grim obligation or a mix of “should” and “must.”
Takeaways
This paradoxical thinking might be the result of a temporary, transitional era. We still value the idea of being informed, but the delivery methods and sources are broken for many. We are overwhelmed by the noise, skeptical of the sources, and increasingly isolated in our own “fact-checking” bubbles.
The challenge moving forward isn’t just finding more news but engaging it without burnout. That could look like restricting news hours, focusing on local reporting that actually impacts your daily life, or acknowledging that doing your own research requires practice and patience. 🟦
Sign up for emails to access early models of the CivicHaven chat application. Article opinions are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of CivicHaven.